Held Up in Private Equity: Navigating Longer Hold Periods Through Value Creation

The private equity (PE) landscape is experiencing a significant shift. Longer hold periods have become increasingly common, primarily due to exit backlogs that inflate Assets Under Management (AUM). This extension in holding durations directly impacts the Internal Rate of Return (IRR), a critical metric for PE firms and their investors. As IRR is sensitive to time, prolonged exits can diminish perceived performance, even if the absolute returns remain strong.

To mitigate the adverse effects of extended hold periods on IRR, PE firms are turning to Value Creation strategies. By actively enhancing the operational performance of their portfolio companies (portcos), firms aim to accelerate growth, improve profitability, and ultimately achieve superior exit valuations. Central to this approach is the role of Operating Partners, who bring specialized expertise to drive transformative initiatives within portcos.

This article delves into the challenges posed by longer hold periods, explores the strategies PE firms are adopting to counteract these challenges, and highlights the importance of collaborative value creation efforts. Drawing inspiration from Thomas C. Anderson and Mark Habner's insightful guide, "Restructuring the Hold", we will examine key themes essential for maximizing value during the portco holding period.

The Challenge of Longer Hold Periods in Private Equity

Exit Backlogs and Increased AUM

The global economic climate, geopolitical uncertainties, and market volatility have contributed to a slowdown in exit activities. This bottleneck has led to an accumulation of portfolio companies awaiting divestiture, thereby increasing the overall AUM for many PE firms.

Impact on Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

IRR is a time-sensitive measure of investment performance. Longer hold periods mean that returns are realized over an extended timeframe, which can lower the IRR even if the total value generated remains substantial. This scenario poses a challenge for PE firms in demonstrating strong performance metrics to their investors.

Investor Expectations and Competitive Pressures

Investors increasingly demand not just absolute returns but also timely realizations. PE firms face competitive pressures to showcase favorable IRRs to attract and retain limited partners (LPs). Therefore, addressing the implications of prolonged holding periods is critical for sustaining investor confidence.

Value Creation: The Strategic Response

To counter the effects of longer hold periods, PE firms are intensifying their focus on Value Creation within their portfolio companies. This proactive approach involves implementing strategies that enhance operational efficiency, drive revenue growth, and improve profitability, thereby increasing the enterprise value ahead of exit.

The Role of Operating Partners

Operating Partners (OPs) are seasoned executives with deep industry expertise and operational acumen. They work closely with portco management teams to identify opportunities for improvement and execute value-enhancing initiatives. Their involvement is pivotal in bridging the gap between strategic objectives and operational execution.

Key Themes for Maximizing Value During the Holding Period

Drawing inspiration from "Restructuring the Hold" by Thomas C. Anderson and Mark Habner, the following key themes emerge as essential for success during the portco holding period:

1. Collaborative Partnerships Between PE Firms and Portco Management

A strong, collaborative relationship between the PE firm and the portco management team is fundamental. This partnership should be characterized by:

• Shared Vision: Aligning on strategic goals and the end-state vision for the company.
• Open Communication: Maintaining transparent and frequent dialogue to address challenges and celebrate milestones.
• Mutual Trust: Building confidence in each other's capabilities and intentions.

Approximately 30% of Anderson and Habner's guide emphasizes the importance of this collaborative dynamic.

2. Establishing a Structured Operating Rhythm

Implementing a consistent operating rhythm ensures that all parties are aligned and focused on key objectives. This includes:

• Regular Reporting: Developing infrastructure for consistent reporting on Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).
• Strategic Meetings: Scheduling periodic reviews to assess progress and adjust strategies as needed.
• Accountability Mechanisms: Defining roles and responsibilities to ensure ownership of initiatives.

3. Developing and Adapting a Value Creation Plan (VCP)

A robust Value Creation Plan serves as a roadmap for achieving the investment thesis. Key aspects include:

• Initial Assessment: Conducting thorough due diligence to identify value creation opportunities.
• Actionable Strategies: Outlining specific initiatives with clear timelines and resource allocation.
• Flexibility: Regularly reviewing and adjusting the VCP to respond to market dynamics and operational realities.

4. Intentional Execution Through Effective Program Management

Driving execution requires disciplined program management focused on delivering tangible business outcomes:

• Milestone Tracking: Setting interim goals to measure progress toward overarching objectives.
• Performance Monitoring: Continuously assessing financial metrics such as EBITDA growth.
• Resource Optimization: Allocating human and capital resources efficiently to support key initiatives.

5. Preparing for Exit to Deliver Outsized Returns

The culmination of the holding period is the exit event, which should be strategically planned:

• Market Timing: Evaluating market conditions to identify optimal exit windows.
• Value Demonstration: Showcasing the enhanced value through improved operational metrics and growth prospects.
• Stakeholder Alignment: Ensuring that investors, PE firms, portco management, and employees are aligned and benefit from the successful exit.

The Ownership Mindset: A Cultural Imperative

Success during the holding period is not solely about strategic plans and operational processes; it also hinges on cultivating an ownership mindset across all parties involved. This mindset encompasses:

• Agility: The ability to switch between different activities swiftly and effectively.
• Confidence with Humility: Having healthy egos that are confident yet open to learning and collaboration.
• Focus on the End State: Keeping the ultimate vision in sight to drive sustained effort and commitment.
• Strong Work Ethic: Demonstrating dedication and resilience in pursuing value creation objectives.

The Role of VCII in Enhancing Value Creation Efforts

The Value Creation Innovation Institute (VCII) is dedicated to empowering PE firms and portco management teams with the tools, insights, and expertise needed to excel during the holding period. VCII offers:

• Strategic Advisory Services: Providing guidance on developing and implementing effective VCPs.
• Operational Excellence Programs: Training and resources to enhance execution capabilities.
• Leadership Development: Cultivating the ownership mindset and collaborative culture essential for success.
• Data-Driven Insights: Leveraging analytics to inform decision-making and track progress against KPIs.

By partnering with VCII, PE firms can augment their value creation efforts, navigate the challenges of longer hold periods, and achieve superior returns for all stakeholders.

The trend of longer hold periods in private equity necessitates a proactive and strategic response. By intensifying focus on value creation and leveraging the expertise of operating partners, PE firms can mitigate the impact on IRR and deliver exceptional outcomes. Collaboration, structured operating rhythms, adaptable value creation plans, intentional execution, and strategic exit planning are critical components of this approach.

Adopting an ownership mindset across all parties ensures that everyone is aligned, agile, and committed to the shared vision. With the support of organizations like the Value Creation Innovation Institute (VCII), PE firms are better equipped to navigate the complexities of the holding period and maximize value for investors, management teams, and employees alike.

#PrivateEquity #ValueCreation #OperatingPartners #InvestmentStrategy #VCII #PortcoManagement #IRR #ExitPlanning #Collaboration #OwnershipMindset